Monday, September 10, 2007

Ask and They Might Just Answer

I am going to be a little self-centered right now. I know you are shocked. A blogger announcing he is going to be self-centered is kind of like a fish announcing his intent to go swimming. A person does not write page after page expressing their opinions on any and everything without being just a tad bit self-involved, but I still feel I owe you, my loyal reader, a warning that I am going to go above and beyond with the patting of my back right now. Read on with that in mind.

We have all heard the stories of the “vanishing Honeybee” I am sure. If you haven't, it seems that Honeybees are disappearing all over the place with no corpses left behind and little understanding of exactly why this is happening at this time. There are theories ranging from “global warming” to “disease within the bee community” to “media manipulation of a non-story.” The simple truth is that no one really knows for certain where the bees are going or why.

Last week, Alan Boyle, who is the Science Editor for MSNBC, wrote a column further discussing the virus theory and the story rose many questions in my mind as I read it. They were not problems with his reporting at all., but rather just questions I have had and that the media has yet to address, so I emailed him with the questions.

This email was sent last week and quickly forgotten by me. I tend to question so many stories on a daily basis that I cannot keep track of them all. I figured that he would email me with a response if my questions were valid and would ignore them if they were not. Today I saw this:


If there are no dead bees being found, then how can we say for certain they are dying? Can the Africanized honey bees and their migration into the United States be a contributing factor if not a cause? Do we know if regular honeybees migrate and, if so, do we know anything about the patterns or timing? How long exactly have we been keeping track of bee movements? If it is less than, say, 200 years, can we really rule out that this is just a pre-existing pattern? - Brad Schader

"They're not finding the dead bees in high numbers, which actually is a good indicator of what's going on," Evans said. If, for instance, pesticides were the primary factor behind the flight of the honeybee, scientists would expect to find bunches of dead bees lying around the hive. Instead, it looks as if the individual bees just fly off and die.

"Do they simply peter out and lose energy? Or do they actually get disoriented? Both of those have been tied to diseases in the past," Evans said.

Bee turnover rates are typically high during the summer foraging season, Evans acknowledged. "In the summer, a 20,000-bee colony will completely turn over in about 30 days," he said.

Penn State entomologist Diana Cox-Foster, the lead author for the Science study, provided some additional perspective in an e-mail. If statistics scare you, feel free to skip over these paragraphs:

There is more, but I don't want to bore you with science. Click the link for the full answer to my question.

I must thank Alan Boyle for answering it so thoroughly. My questions are validated, answered, and it went far beyond what I expected. I am also flattered that he used my letter as a part of his recent column. This is the “back patting” part of my post by the way.

Lesson to the lemmings- write journalists about stories you read. They may respond. I think they are like us, only without the comment section.

6 comments:

Serena Joy said...

Cool! Sometimes I get replies, sometimes not. Usually not.

Camille Alexa said...

Okay. If you felt you were losing me before, I am riveted by this one. Not only is this a nicely written post, it's way cool to hear that you actually correspond with journalisty and sciency types, and even cooler to know they publicly respond. AND you blogged about news far more timeworthy and relevant than blond train-wrecks. I love this, Kanrei. Bravo.

ThatGreenyFlower said...

Question authority...in public. Well-done, Kan!

Kanrei said...

Thanks. It was beyond a shock to see my name first thing in the morning without my having written it. It is inspiring to keep at it.

Biride, there is a funk going around. I have been under it, SM has been under it, and you may be. It is affecting my writing for certain right now, so maybe it is affecting your enjoyment of certain writings. There is certainly something to both me and SM feeling our mojos slipping and your not feeling our mojos. That cannot be only you.

That you Greeny. If they will not answer our questions on their own, we must force them I suppose.

Camille Alexa said...

I could do with some mojo infusion my own self.

goldennib said...

This is great. Your questions were good ones.