I’m still not going to spoil the Killing Joke here, but I do
feel the need to address why I love this story in light of the negative press
it is once again receiving. And much
of this press is rightly deserved in my not so humble opinion as the writers
made choices I personally wish they had not made. The main writer has also expressed regret
over some choices he made while writing it, so I am not alone in my critique, but I also see how those choices do work in the narrative of the story and actually
makes sense in the demented outlook of the character driving the story. They are choices I would not have made, but
do not distract from the overall story for me.
What makes the Killing Joke unique and special to me is that
Alan Moore took a character famous for his lack of motive and gave him a very
strict focus; a purpose. Joker was not
out to “watch the world burn” as Nolan’s Joker did. He is not engaging in some comical criminal
plot as a device for a child’s cartoon.
He is not seeking vengeance or any other contrived comic book villain
plot in any way, shape, or form this time.
This time he is seeking something everyone can relate too: understanding
and vindication of who he became. He
needs to know that what he became is not his fault and that anyone would have
followed his path if given his circumstances.
It is the most human motive I have seen for a comic villain outside of
Magneto’s desire to prevent another holocaust. It is a motive even Batman himself could
relate to.
Again, without spoilers, Joker believes his life is the end
result of “one bad day.” He then
surmises that Batman’s life is also a result of “one bad day.” If “one bad day” can make Batman into Batman
and Joker into Joker, then “one bad day’ should change anyone. He finds the most honest person he can find,
Commissioner Gordon, and subjects him to a truly bad day in the hopes of
proving his theory correct, thus vindicating himself and showing that he could
have just as easily been Batman and, more importantly, Batman could have just
as easily become him. It is the details
of this “bad day” that have caused so much controversy around The Killing Joke,
but it does fit within the context of the “bad day’ Joker himself suffered. And yes, we do get an origin story for the
Joker, but even he admits it could be pure fiction.
What makes the Killing Joke such a monumental comic and
story is that the writers took two huge figures in American Mythology, a hero
and a villain who traditionally are at odds with one another, and showed they
were more alike than they were different.
It showed us that anyone could become a hero or a villain based on the
circumstances of their lives and makes us wonder, if given the depths of that “one
bad day” if we would be Joker, Batman, or Gordon when the day was over.